Notice: wp_enqueue_script was called incorrectly. Scripts and styles should not be registered or enqueued until the wp_enqueue_scripts, admin_enqueue_scripts, or login_enqueue_scripts hooks. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 3.3.0.) in /home/immigration/public_html/wp-includes/functions.php on line 4138
Non-EU migrants should be cut by 25%, says MAC | Immigration Matters

Want to learn more about UK/EU Immigration Law? Click Act Now to learn more... Act Now

Call Us +44 7950 458 464 |
 Categories : News


The number of migrant workers coming to Britain from outside the EU should be cut by between 13% and 25% next year, government experts have said.

But even this will only contribute 20% to the government’s target of reducing UK immigration to “tens of thousands”, says the migration advisory committee.

The other 80% cut would have come from student and family migration, it adds.

The committee’s advice will help ministers in setting the cap, which will come into effect next April.

Committee chairman Professor David Metcalf said the number of visas for skilled workers issued under what is called Tier One and Tier Two needs to be between 37,400 and 43,700 for 2011/12.

This would represent a cut of up to 12,600 from the 50,000 in 2009, he said.

Immigration minister Damian Green said the government would announce their decision on the cap “shortly”.


He said: “Bringing down net migration to sustainable levels will not be easy. We will not be able to achieve it by focusing on just one area of the system or on one route into Britain.

“By introducing an annual limit we will reduce the number of people who come to the UK to work from outside the EU.

“But this is just one of the ways we intend to reduce the level of net migration back down to the tens of thousands each year.”

He insisted the cap could be introduced without damaging Britain’s economy.

The government has already made a major concession to industry, by exempting intra-company transfers from it, which account for the majority of skilled workers coming into the UK through Tier Two of the points-based system.

The committee’s report also paves the way for a clampdown on people entering the UK on elite Tier One visas, meant for the “brightest and best” migrants.

This is the only category of non-EU migrant allowed to enter the UK without a job offer, but research by the UK Border Agency has found almost one in three migrants who came in through this route were in menial roles such as shop assistants, security guards and supermarket cashiers.

Home Secretary Theresa May has said that Tier One of the visa system should only be used by investors, entrepreneurs and people of exceptional talent.

And the committee’s report backs this up, recommending that Tier Two visas, for skilled workers with job offers, should be prioritised over Tier One visas.

The report also concludes that tier 1 and tier 2 migration clearly has a positive impact on Gross Domestic Product (GDP).

Student Visas

The report also calls for more effort to ensure British workers were trained up so that businesses can recruit the skilled people they need, without having to bring them in from abroad. EU citizens, with the exception of those from Romania and Bulgaria, are free to work in the UK without restrictions.

The number of student visas rose from 250,000 in 2008 to just over 300,000 (including 30,000 student dependants) in 2009 following the introduction of Tier 4 of the points based system, the system introduced to make it easier for students to come and study in the UK.

Going a little further back, previous Prime Minister Tony Blair started two ‘Prime Ministerial Initiatives’ specifically to increase the UK’s share of the lucrative FE and HE education market.

As a result, changes to the immigration rules were introduced allowing students more flexibility to switch into working routes under Tier 1 and 2, as well as introducing the automatic entitlement to work during term time.

Prime Minister David Cameron has said he wants to bring net migration down from 196,000 a year to “tens of thousands” by 2015, despite pleas from industry and universities who claim their ability to recruit top level scientists and researchers could be harmed.

Prof Metcalf said: “It is not possible to reduce net migration to the tens of thousands by limiting work-related migration alone.

“The committee assumes that work-related migration takes 20% of the total cut – its fair share – which implies that family and student migration must take the other 80%.”

In September, Theresa May announced an interim cap, limiting the number of non-EU workers allowed into the UK to 24,100 – down around 5% – to April 2011.

But the Commons home affairs committee said in a report earlier this month that the government had no chance of fulfilling its pledge to cut immigration without further curbs on international students and those joining family members in the UK.

Migrants may even have to be stripped of their right to settle in the UK in the long term to bring the numbers down, the MPs said.

It found the proposed cap could affect fewer than one in 100 migrants entering the UK. Source: BBC

Dominic Casciani, BBC News home affairs correspondent, said:

‘Professor David Metcalf’s report on how to limit migration isn’t 324 pages long for nothing. It’s because the government’s goal of slashing net migration to tens of thousands is so very challenging.

‘What’s clear is that the target cannot be met simply by severely limiting skilled workers from outside of Europe, an approach that could have “long-term consequences” for the economy.

‘Some of the answers will lie in raising the bar for entry and longer-term measures to “boost outflows” – policies to stop migrants settling or switching jobs.

‘Ministers will also have to think about cutting foreign students and the legally-fraught area of family-related settlement.

‘If these policies levers can be pulled, the pressure to limit highly talented non-European workers will ease.

‘The question in the subtext is something that goes beyond the coalition’s domestic goals: Can any government in a globalised world prevent the movement of people?’

Students contribute £8.3 billion to UK

The government also needs to consider what impact reducing migrant workers and students will have on its efforts to boost the economy and slash the deficit.

Business leaders argue that they need the flexibility to recruit workers from abroad to fill skills gaps in areas where the independent Migration Advisory Committee have advised the Home Office that a shortage exists.

Students, who should not be treated as ‘migrants’ at all as they do not accrue any settlement rights whilst on a student visa and have no entitlement to state benefits, are worth £8.3 billion to the UK economy, according to the UK Border Agency.

Education is a still a world leading brand and a major ‘export’ for the UK, which is vital to the country’s recovery.

Destroying Britain’s market leading position in education, and in the process thousands of jobs, would be utter madness.

Worst still, students will simply spend their billions elsewhere in countries like Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Germany, Singapore and the US, which recognize their economic contribution and will ‘bite their arms off’ to have them.

Most of Britain’s manufacturing jobs have been ‘exported’ to Asia and Eastern Europe, our large banks and multi-national corporations have exported white collar jobs to India and many of the FTSE 100 companies are now in foreign ownership.

Successive governments have allowed our manufacturing industries to decline whilst selling off the family silver. The country relies heavily on financial services and the City, but is this enough?

The questions we need to consider are:

  • What products do British owned companies have left to sell abroad in a competitive global market?
  • If we do not sell goods or services to other countries how is Britain going to survive, let alone reverse the long term post-war decline?

Migrants do not only bring their labour or cash into the UK, they also bring energy entrepreneurship and a desire to start businesses which provide jobs and pay taxes.

The Home Affairs Committee report published on 3 November warns against what appears to be a ‘consistent tendency, under both the current and previous Governments, to rush through complex changes to the immigration system via amendments to the Immigration Rules rather than through primary legislation’.

Chair of the Committee, Rt Hon Keith Vaz, said: 

“Successive governments have enacted changes to the immigration system with almost immediate effect, bypassing parliamentary conventions.

“Such unnecessary haste leads to poor decision-making which is more likely to be challenged in the courts. 

“The Government must ensure that Parliament be given the opportunity fully to scrutinise all significant changes to the immigration system before they are introduced. 

“We were particularly concerned about the potential effect on  international students of a reduction in immigration, seeing as they account for around 25% of total long-term immigration each year. 

“Although the Government has not yet unveiled plans for reform of student immigration, our evidence underlined the crucial importance of international students to the cultural and intellectual life, as well as the finances, of UK educational institutions. 

The Government should direct its efforts to tackling those who abuse the system – bogus colleges and visa overstayers – rather than penalising legitimate students”.

Have your say

Are you a migrant worker or student from outside the EU?

Are you a business owner relying on skilled, non-EU labour?

How will you be affected by the proposed cap?

See also:

Immigration cap insults NHS workers says leading Doctor

Cap on immigration won’t cut numbers sufficiently say MP’s

UK Immigration Cap could damage higher education

Immigration cap will cost UK top scientists warns Nobel laureate

UK Border Agency Video on English language tests for migrant partners

If you need any immigration advice or help with Sponsorship or Work Permits, Visa, ILR/Settlement, Citizenship, dependant visa or an appeal against a refusal please email: or visit

Spread the Word, like or share this page, your friends will also love it and thanks for it.

Do you employ foreign workers? Don't risk a £20,000 fine and a possible custodial sentence. We can advice on Entrepreneur Visas, Investor Visas and Home Office sponsor licence compliance for your business. Use the button below to schedule an appointment...


Immigration Adviser, Speaker and Author See also: Profile - Profile:!/groups/14119859749/

10 Responses to “Non-EU migrants should be cut by 25%, says MAC”
Read them below or add one

  1. why arethese students concerned in getting thier dependants even they are not halfway with the course.its your choice to be away with them and focus more on your studies because what you need is the certificate .after finishing the course you will go home.nvq will only take 3 months to finish.

  2. […] Non-EU migrants should be cut by 25%, says MAC […]

  3. Ramesh Kumar says :

    They need people who can do cleaning services and also they money from students who come to this country not to earn degrees but to seek entry only.They also love feel pride give visas to asylum seekers who are richer then persons earning more then £40K.There are more then 1M people illegally leaving in this country.There are hundred of thousands of people who do not pay taxes and fraud on vat. Thousands of take away do not pay taxes and employ illegal people.Tier 1 is mockery , when i asked some one who came to my home to deliver pizza what visa he holds.He replied Tier-1 , highly skilled .Do you need high skills in this job?

  4. […] Non-EU migrants should be cut by 25%, says MAC […]

  5. […] He spoke a few days after the Migration Advisory Committee, charged with advising the government on migration, said the number of skilled workers from outside the European Union allowed into Britain should be cut by up to 25%. […]

  6. […] Metcalf also recommended a 13 to 25 per cent cut in the number of “Tier 1″ highly-skilled workers and “Tier 2&#8243…, despite worries from employers that they will be unable to fill key […]

  7. Ifeanyi says :

    It seems what the UK Government is interested in is bringing students in, make them pay huge fees and spend the money they brought from their home country in the UK, after which they are flushed out, without consideration.

    The interest I think is only on the money they collect from us and not our potential to contribute in an economy we have assisted to grow. The fact remains that there are other economies that are yearning for migrants like, Canada, Australia, the US, etc.

    So students and people have options where to migrate to.

  8. asm.fakhruzzaman says :

    I am a student in the UK under tire4 rules,I have 33 month valid visas,my course is tourism and hospitality management(with 3 month language course). My visas valid start time is 25/12/2009. I’m married,my wife live in Bangladesh. I’m always upset because i miss my wife, she is 22 years old, How can get a spouse visa for my wife? what kind of rule we can fallow? I don’t know anything but it’s necessary for me because i want to complete my graduation in UK with my wife. Please give me full rules and law.

    Thanks for your help.

  9. […] The JCWI has issued a press release following this week’s report by the Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) recommending a 25% cut in non-EU migrants:  […]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked by *.

You must beLogged in to post a comment.