Notice: wp_enqueue_script was called incorrectly. Scripts and styles should not be registered or enqueued until the wp_enqueue_scripts, admin_enqueue_scripts, or login_enqueue_scripts hooks. Please see Debugging in WordPress for more information. (This message was added in version 3.3.0.) in /home/immigration/public_html/wp-includes/functions.php on line 4138
Labour got it wrong on EU immigration, says Ed Miliband | Immigration Matters

Want to learn more about UK/EU Immigration Law? Click Act Now to learn more... Act Now

Call Us +44 7950 458 464 |
 Categories : News


The Labour Party leader has conceded that the former Labour government allowed too many Eastern European immigrants into country by lifting controls too early.

Ed Miliband has signalled a major change in Labour’s immigration policy by disclosing he wants to change the economic rules to do more to help people already living and working in Britain.

In an interview with the Guardian, he concedes that immigration is being discussed in “every kitchen” and that the Labour party has been too quick to dismisses the concerns of ordinary people as “prejudice”.

He says the government should strengthen the law so that employment agencies cannot – even informally – favour foreign workers.

“In sectors where there is a problem, every medium and large employer that has more than 25% foreign workers – double the average share of migrants in the population – should have to notify Jobcentre Plus.”

Miliband said he wanted to “reframe” the debate on immigration by pledging to reform a “brutish labour market” that encourages the excessive use of low-paid immigrants and allows British companies to shirk their responsibilities to train workers. But he distanced himself from remarks made by the former Prime Minister Gordon Brown, suggesting that it would be wrong to promise too much. “We cannot tell people things we cannot deliver. We cannot say ‘British jobs for British workers’.”

He admitted the Labour government allowed too many immigrants from Eastern Europe into the country by lifting controls on EU accession countries such as Poland too quickly, but denied his party lied about immigration, as claimed by his former adviser Lord Glasman.

Miliband argued that immigration should be seen as a class issue, since the evidence shows lower-paid workers and the unskilled suffer disproportionately, especially from the impact of cheap eastern European labour. He said he was entering the debate on immigration in the context of his call for a more responsible capitalism.

“There has been a collision of a large amount of immigration from Eastern Europe and a UK labour market that is frankly too often nasty, brutish and short-term,” he said.

As part of a policy review, Miliband proposes sanctions against labour agencies that advertise solely for immigrant workers, an early warning system if some industries are employing disproportionately large number of foreign workers, a doubling of fines if employers undercut the minimum wage, and no early lifting of migrant barriers for new EU countries such as Croatia.  

He also told the Guardian he would review immigrants’ access to benefits and “local connection” rules for council house waiting lists. “There are issues around the pace of change in communities, pressures on public resources and making sure entitlements work fairly,” he said.

“There are clearly issues that people have been raising over a number of years. We have to look at where the rules are right and, if they are wrong, what we can do about it. You have to have the right entitlements in place.”

Miliband said: “We have got to talk about this issue because the public are talking about it. I am for politics that is relevant to people’s lives. We cannot have a debate going on in every kitchen, street and every neighbourhood and the Labour party not talk about it.”

He said: “Labour has to change its approach to immigration but you cannot answer people’s concerns on immigration unless you change the way your economy works.

“Overall, immigration has benefits, but the thing we did not talk about was its relevance to class, and the issue of where the benefits and burdens lie. If you need a builder, it is good that there are more coming into the country and lowering the price of construction, but if you are a British builder it is less beneficial.

“In government we were not sufficiently alive to the burdens, so when people said they were concerned that their wages were being driven down by people from eastern Europe our response too often was to argue that these people are saying ‘stop the world, I want to get off’, or at worst ‘this is prejudice’. I think we were too starry-eyed about globalisation’s benefits.

“We have to confront the fact you cannot address people’s concerns about immigration unless you change the way the economy works.

“It is the short-term, fast-buck culture that is at the root of this, so we have to look at what incentives we can give companies so they do not rely on a pool of short-term temporary labour that will come to this country and go away again.”

He said he did not advocate ending the free movement of labour within the European Union, or even think it possible.

Miliband said he was not “trying to mischaracterise Gordon Brown” over his controversial speech on British jobs for British workers in 2007. “But the problem is that phrase came across as giving the impression we were promising to do something we cannot deliver.” He said fact and anecdote had to be separated in the debate, pointing to evidence that immigration drove down wages mainly in lower-paid sectors, and created unemployment only in some localised markets such as catering, construction and food processing.

Although government evidence shows that 370,000 people who came to the country as foreign nationals are claiming benefits, Miliband pointed out that proportionately fewer migrants were claiming benefits than in the UK labour force.

Polling recently published by Policy Exchange shows that a Labour shift on immigration and welfare would be the single most important issues to win back Labour swing voters.

A Conservative spokeswoman said: “Ed Miliband says he is not going to promise British jobs for British workers, but he seems to have fallen into same trap as Gordon Brown. He still opposes everything the government is going to do to cut and control immigration, and still is not offering a single credible immigration policy of his own.” Source: The Guardian.

The Labour Government underestimated the impact of the EU expansion and the fact that most other European countries imposed 7 year restrictions on A8 nations such as Poland, Slovakia and Hungary.

The then Immigration Minister Tony McNulty famously predicted that 13,000 EU migrants would come to the UK in 2004. In the following few years over half a million Eastern Europeans migrated to Britain.

However, when A2 accession countries, Bulgaria and Romania joined the EU in 2007, working restrictions were imposed by the UK and others until 2014.

See also:

How Romanians and Bulgarians working illegally without Yellow Card or papers can legalise their status in the UK

Immigration Rules for Bulgarian and Romanian nationals


Yellow or Blue Card Refused – Appeal or Reapply?

7 tips for completing a Yellow Card BR1 application to work and study in the UK

Health care workers needed in UK now

Employment restrictions for Bulgarians and Romanians extended until end of 2013

Majestic College offer special packages for EU students. They also have a number of employers looking for staff right now and are willing to employ Bulgarians and Romanians. For more information call Joanna on 0208 207 1020 or email

Spread the Word, like or share this page, your friends will also love it and thanks for it.

Do you employ foreign workers? Don't risk a £20,000 fine and a possible custodial sentence. We can advice on Entrepreneur Visas, Investor Visas and Home Office sponsor licence compliance for your business. Use the button below to schedule an appointment...


Immigration Adviser, Speaker and Author See also: Profile - Profile:!/groups/14119859749/

2 Responses to “Labour got it wrong on EU immigration, says Ed Miliband”
Read them below or add one

  1. […] Labour leader Ed Miliband’s criticism of Blair’s EU immigration policy, the former PM has spoken out saying that he does not regret the decision to lift border controls […]

  2. […] of Gordon Brown talking about British jobs for British workers. Unless they are proposing to rewrite the rules of the European Union they could be promising to deliver in an area where action is least […]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked by *.

You must beLogged in to post a comment.